Best Restaurants in Downtown Indianapolis

Indianapolis is more than the Crossroads of America—it’s a haven for food lovers. Whether you’re a local looking to try something new or a tourist exploring the Circle City, downtown Indianapolis has a dining scene that caters to every palate and occasion.

From upscale dining experiences to cozy breakfast spots, this guide will take you through the best restaurants downtown Indy offers. Let’s indulge in the culinary gems of one of America’s most dynamic cities!

Top Restaurants in Indianapolis

Indianapolis’ top restaurants blend exceptional flavors, refined ambiance, and top-tier service to create memorable dining experiences.

St. Elmo Steak House

A landmark since 1902, St. Elmo Steak House is the epitome of fine dining in Indianapolis. Known for its rich history and legendary shrimp cocktail with a fiery horseradish kick, this iconic steakhouse offers perfectly aged steaks and fresh seafood in a warm, elegant setting. It’s a must-visit for anyone who wants to savor Indy’s culinary heritage.

Bluebeard

Located in the historic Fletcher Place neighborhood, Bluebeard offers a contemporary take on American cuisine. The menu changes daily based on locally sourced ingredients, so expect dishes that are as innovative as they are delicious. The rustic yet sleek ambiance paired with flavorful creations makes it an unforgettable dining experience.

Beholder

A true gem for adventurous foodies, Beholder redefines fine dining with uniquely crafted dishes featuring seasonal ingredients. From fresh oysters to artistic small plates, every dish delivers an unforgettable sensory experience complimented by the restaurant’s chic and stylish interior.

Date Night in Indy: Best Dining Spots in Indianapolis

Indianapolis offers plenty of romantic options for an elegant evening out with your special someone.

Livery

Housed in a restored 1890s building, Livery combines Latin flavors with a modern touch. Share dishes like empanadas and skirt steak tacos in the intimate, candlelit upstairs dining area, or enjoy a cocktail on the rooftop patio under the city lights. It’s perfect for an unforgettable date night.

The Eagle

Rustic charm meets elevated comfort food at The Eagle. This gastropub focuses on fried chicken that’s golden perfection paired with classic Southern sides like spoonbread and mac ‘n’ cheese. Its relaxed vibe sets the stage for a laid-back yet cozy evening out.

Vida

One of the city’s few AAA Four Diamond restaurants, Vida specializes in contemporary American cuisine with a farm-to-table focus. Their multi-course menus are designed for culinary discovery, offering everything from duck liver mousse to octopus carpaccio. Vida’s sophisticated ambiance is the perfect backdrop for any upscale date night.

Casual Indy Restaurants

Try these casual Indianapolis eateries for laid-back dining that doesn’t compromise flavor:

• Shapiro’s Delicatessen. A downtown staple for over a century, Shapiro’s Delicatessen offers hearty sandwiches with New York-style corned beef and pastrami. Enjoy a slice of house-made pie for the ultimate comfort food experience.
• BRU Burger Bar. On Massachusetts Avenue, BRU Burger Bar offers gourmet twists on classic burgers, featuring options like the Bourbon Burger and brie-topped Salmon Burger, plus an impressive beer selection. 
• City Market. The vibrant Indianapolis City Market features diverse food vendors, from global street food to fresh pastries, ideal for those who enjoy sampling a variety in a lively setting.

Breakfast and Brunch: Great Restaurants in Indianapolis

Mornings in Indy are truly enhanced by its stellar breakfast spots, each offering unique flavors and experiences. From cozy cafes serving homemade pastries and freshly brewed coffee to vibrant diners that whip up classic breakfast dishes with a gourmet twist, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

Milktooth

Transforming breakfast into a fine dining affair, Milktooth is a brunch spot like no other. Tucked away in Fletcher Place, this award-winning café offers inventive takes on morning favorites—think Dutch baby pancakes and sorghum glazed bacon.

Yolk

Known for its creative menu and generous portions, Yolk has become a go-to spot for brunch lovers in Indy. Whether you’re craving classic eggs Benedict or a build-your-own skillet breakfast, this casual eatery has it all. Plus, their refreshing mimosas are a must-try.

Café Patachou

A casual yet refined breakfast staple, Café Patachou is famous for its broken yolk sandwiches and local farm-to-table ethos. It’s a comfortable space offering healthy, delicious options to start your day off right.

Indianapolis Food Everyone Should Try Once

To truly experience the city, you have to try its signature flavors.

• Shrimp Cocktail at St. Elmo Steak House. This famous shrimp cocktail is not just food—it’s an Indy institution. The unforgettable mix of chilled shrimp and eye-watering horseradish cocktail sauce is a must-try.
• Sugar Cream Pie. Known as Indiana’s state pie, Sugar Cream Pie is a simple yet delightful dessert found in many bakeries downtown, like Pots & Pans Pie Co. The caramelized, creamy filling on a flaky crust is pure nostalgia.
• Tenderloin Sandwich. Synonymous with Indiana comfort food, the breaded pork tenderloin sandwich is larger than life. You’ll find some of the best versions right in downtown Indy, from restaurants like The Rathskeller to local diners.

Find Your Flavor in Downtown Indy

No matter your tastes, downtown Indianapolis serves up a culinary experience you won’t soon forget. From lavish fine dining to casual bites, each meal is seasoned with the city’s welcoming charm. Are you looking for a new apartment near Indianapolis? HILLS Properties has two luxury apartment homes in Indiana. Find your perfect apartment at Wellington Place or Emerald Lakes today, and bon appétit!